Contact Us   |   Print Page   |   Sign In   |   Join HRPS
April 2015 Blogs
Blog Home All Blogs
Search all posts for:   


View all (3) posts »

The Neuroscience Behind Trust, Rapport and Faith: When Leadership Goes Awry

Posted By Administration, Tuesday, April 07, 2015
Updated: Monday, April 06, 2015

By Sophia Kristjansson


A few weeks ago, I was sitting on hard bleachers in a basketball arena listening to my favorite podcast while my nephew practiced basketball with his elite team. All seemed to be going well until the team moved into position to sprint the lines. Its a familiar sight to anyone who has played competitive sports. The exercise builds speed and stamina, but its also a way to punish the players when theyre not following the coachs lead. This scenario is played out for us in the movie Miracle, when Coach Brooks forces the players to sprint the lines because they were treating the exhibition game against Norway as a joke. They skated back and forth across the ice late into the night until one team member, exhausted, self-identified as being part of the 1980 U.S. Olympic Team, rather than the name on the back of his jersey. The point: Their sum was greater than their parts.


Though my nephews coach had similar intentions, he lacked Herb Brooks finesse. The players werent running drills correctly to build their speed, agility, and "teammanship." For some reason, coach and team werent connecting and the anger became personal. After running the lines, the coach called the players worthless, told them they werent worth developing, yelled that they were wasting his time, dared them to take a step, and threatened their advancement by telling them theyd never achieve the next level of basketball. I could go on. 


Although the players said nothing, I could see the impact of the coachs words their faces and in their body language. These young men stopped moving their feet, looked visibly stressed, and stopped communicating with one another while performing the drills. What I saw in these young players nonverbal cues was similar to what I witness in organizations when a leader grossly misbehaves: a loss of trust, rapport and faith.  


As the rant continued, I reflected on leadership. The truth is that my nephews coach is frustrated because he doesnt know how to get more out of his players.  Hes tried everything, but they still dont perform to his expectations. Because hes lost his ability to lead, the players wont try to improve under his direction. They dont understand what they need to do differently because hes not reaching them, and as their leader this is his primary responsibility.  Everyone loses in this scenariocoach, player, basketball club, and school, and the rotten sentiment that follows this coach wont go away. The impact of his actions is definitive, forever seared into the players psyche. All they know is that they dont want to perform for someone who treats them like that. 


This can happen in any organization. Once a leader has a reputation, its almost impossible to shake. 


In these kinds of tension-filled situationswhen we lose our trust and faith in a leader we previously respectedwhats happening behind the scenes that creates such an indelible experience for us? Our inner reptile holds one key. When we experience a situation that makes us feel unsafe, our reptilian brain (limbic system) takes over and we go into survival mode we no longer employ higher level thought processes like clear decision-making, complex problem solving or creativity. Instead, we react to our environment to determine whether we need to fight, take flight, or freeze. 


Moreover, were all naturally predisposed to focus on negative events rather than positive ones, which leave a more enduring imprint. After all, by doing this we kept ourselves alive throughout the millennia. According to Dr. Evian Gordon, the brain scans the environment every one-fifth of one second to pick up important cues.  This non-conscious process feeds a sensation in our body that in turn creates awareness. From that point we decide what were going to do with it.  In organizations we listen for the ways were spoken to and the slightest hint of judgment raises our negative awareness. We subconsciously know the difference between, What did you think would happen? and Share your thinking. Its an interesting take on the situation. The first is judgmental and the other is inquiry.


The neuroscience behind memory holds another key to our retention of emotional information, thus impacting our perception of leaders. The way someone behaves creates an enduring impression in our minds. The impressions create stories that we remember with emotional clarity, some more clearly than others. In a 2004 study, Kensinger and Corkin wanted to uncover the neural circuits responsible for emotional memory, like an experience that makes us feel good or bad; i.e., news that weve been promoted or a mediocre biannual job review that doesnt accurately reflect our perception of performance. (I personally like this study because they performed both fMRI scans and an accompanying behavioral study, thus connecting wiring to behavior.) 


Kensinger and Corkin found that the amygdalar-hippocampal network of the brain is stimulated by emotionally arousing information (that was either positive or negative in nature), which could have an automatic effect on memory. In other words, this network is specifically engaged when we believe were encountering an emotionally induced situation. Remember that inner reptile, our limbic system? The amygdalar-hippocampal network is part of the ancient limbic system in our brain that assesses threat level. We have a reaction (non-conscious or conscious) to emotionally inducing information that creates an effect on our memory. The memories we create teach us an ongoing lesson about how to approach situations. Therefore, if a leader is abusive, chances are we will not perform well in the presence of this person. It doesnt mean we dont want to do well; it just means were not thinking as clearly as we could. Were naturally more nervous, and this affects our higher cognitive levels.


Think back to a challenging professional situation or even the basketball team. When someone with more status or perceived power treats us poorly, we generally try to please or avoid the person so the emotionally charged experience doesnt repeat. If that person behaves the same way again, we start to create a story that tells us to steer clear of the person or to keep our heads down to avoid conflict. We might get mad and want to retaliate, or even start gossiping. In any case, its probable that the brain isnt evaluating information with the prefrontal cortex to determine how to handle complex problems at that moment in time. Our reptiles have taken over, and the focus is on survival.


Can someone who has been leading poorly and squandering trust overcome the memories others have of him or her and achieve success? Yes and no. Ive seen people change, and Ive also seen those around that person adapt to their change, but they dont forget. When they see the slightest hint that harks back to the original bad behavior, they can easily interpret that the individual hasnt committed to the change. Im hard-pressed to find proof that abusive behavior entices more resolve and better team playing or even business innovation. If you see bad behavior in your organization, look at its impact and find a way to address it quickly. If you dont, the cleanup will be costly on both human and financial levels.


Stay tuned! Next months I'll talk about how to create more rapport on teams.


+ + + + +                    


Sophia Kristjansson is founder and CEO of Lexicon Leadership Group. She is a thought leader and executive coach in the exciting field of the neuroscience of leadership. Her passion is to help people and their organizations better navigate change and influence innovation. She has 15 years of coaching and training experience balanced by more than 12 years in international business, management, and marketing. She regularly writes, speaks, and teaches for a number of organizations and academic institutions.  (Her upcoming book on leadership will be published in 2016.)  Sophia founded Lexicon Leadership Group in 2011. LLG’s work is guided by a deep understanding of neuroscience and its relationship to human development and communication.  LLG specializes in executive coaching, leadership development training and team facilitation, as well as implementation of the Emergenetics suite of tools and solutions for clients across the globe.  Sophia’s serves on the Board of HR People and Strategy.


Tags:  coaching  leadership  neuroscience 

Share |
Permalink | Comments (0)
Association Management Software Powered by YourMembership  ::  Legal